“Ask the Community” Forum

Adaptations: Lost in Translation or a New Perspective?

Adaptations: Lost in Translation or a New Perspective?

av Caoimhe Ní Chearbhaill OLS Irish Community Manager -
Antall svar: 0

Book & Movie Club, Join Us!

Caoimhe Ní Chearbhaill 2023

Ón Leathanach go dtí an Scáileán: Claochlú Scéalta i nOiriúnuithe Leabhar go Scannán"


Dia dhaoibh!


Agus muid ag tumadh isteach inár gClub Leabhar & Scannán, tagann ábhar suimiúil chun cinn: conas a athraíonn scéalta nuair a oireann siad ó leabhair go scannáin? Is féidir leis an aistriú seo ón bhfocal scríofa go scéalaíocht amhairc a bheith draíochtúil, ach tagann sé lena shraith dúshlán agus athruithe féin.


Pointí Plé:


Athruithe i Scéalaíocht: Cad iad na hathruithe is suntasaí a thug tú faoi deara i n-oiriúnuithe leabhar go scannán?

Brabúis agus Caillteanais: Cad iad na heilimintí, dar leat, a bhaintear amach nó a chailltear sa phróiseas oiriúnaithe?

Taithí Phearsanta: Roinn aon oiriúnuithe a chuaigh i bhfeidhm ort go háirithe, go dearfach nó go diúltach.


Bí Páirteach sa Chomhrá:


Roinn Do Léargais: An raibh mothúchán agat riamh go ndearna oiriúnú scannáin feabhas nó dochar don scéal bunaidh? Cén fáth?

Oiriúnuithe is Fearr: Cad iad cuid de na hoiriúnuithe leabhar go scannán is fearr leat agus cén fáth?


Saoirse Chruthaitheach: Cad é do mheas ar léiritheoirí scannáin ag glacadh saoirsí cruthaitheacha leis an ábhar bunaidh?


Déanaimis iniúchadh ar an gcaoi a n-éiríonn an ealaín scéalaíochta nuair a bhogann sí ó leathanaigh leabhair go scáileán an phictiúrlainne. Féadann bhur bpeirspictíochtaí agus taithí soiléire a chur ar an bpróiseas cruthaitheach seo. Téigh isteach sa phlé agus roinnimis ár smaointe ar na claochluithe scéalaíochta seo!

English Translation


Caoimhe Ní Chearbhaill 2023

"From the Page to the Screen: The Transformation of Stories in Book-to-Film Adaptations"


Dia Dhaoibh! 


As we dive into our Book & Movie Club, an interesting subject comes to light: how do stories change when they are adapted from books to films? This transition from the written word to visual storytelling can be magical, but it also comes with its own set of challenges and changes.


Discussion Points:


Changes in Storytelling: What are the most significant changes you have noticed in book-to-film adaptations?Gains and Losses: What elements do you think are gained or lost in the adaptation process?Personal Experience: Share any adaptations that particularly impacted you, either positively or negatively.

Join the Conversation:


Share Your Insights: Have you ever felt that a film adaptation improved or worsened the original story? Why?


Favorite Adaptations: What are some of your favorite book-to-film adaptations, and why?

Creative Liberties: What is your opinion on filmmakers taking creative liberties with the source material?


Let's explore how the art of storytelling evolves as it moves from the pages of a book to the cinema screen. Your perspectives and experiences can illuminate this creative process. Join the discussion and let's share our thoughts on these narrative transformations!

As always, please ensure you follow the OLS Form Netiquette & House Rules when interacting in the community.